[Updated, April 2023] Looking for the best safety toe type? We were too! There are steel toes as well as composite, aluminum, titanium, and alloy toes. Metatarsal guards are for extreme industrial work. Wolverine’s CarbonMax, Red Wing’s aluminum and Timberland’s Titan are great for boots and shoes. Is a toe cap a must for you?
It is great to be concerned about foot safety. Yes, safety toe (or, popularly steel toe) is the prime feature whenever you think about protecting the feet at work. At least, wherever you are working in a risky environment where things may fall or roll over the forefoot. Technology is moving forward at lightning speed. Safety toe features are also evolving.
Here in this article, we are going to discuss each prospect so that you do not miss one valuable point worth noticing.
- 1 What does safety toe cover anyway?
- 2 The 9-Article Safety Toe Series
- 3 Is safety toe the same as composite toe?
- 4 Functions: What are safety toe boots and shoes? what do they do?
- 5 Requirements Vary: Do I need a safety toe?
- 6 TITAN® safety toe: Timberland’s flagship toe class
- 7 Safety toe inserts: just like removable insoles? good or not?
- 8 Can Safety Toes Be Dangerous? Can they completely cut the toes off?
- 9 You May Not Need Safety Toes: Why & when not wearing a safety toe can be better for you?
What does safety toe cover anyway?
Safety toe covers everything. Whether you are looking for steel toe, composite ones, carbon toe, nanotechnology toe, aluminum, titanium, alloy, or other rare breeds like CarbonMax, all of these are falling under safety toe criteria. We even prefer to discuss metatarsal guards under this term which keeps things simple.
Let’s go through the alternative phrases and terms:
Sometimes people say safety boots/shoes/footwear. If it is ‘steel boot’, ‘steel shoe’, ‘steel cap’, ‘safety capped’ or ‘protection/protective’, it means more or less the same.
The 9-Article Safety Toe Series
This post is part of the safety toe series, 9 articles that myth bust, explain, suggest, and answer FAQs on:
- [this article] Safety toe
- Steel toe
- Composite toe
- The Versus article (compares each type of safety toe)
- Carbon/nano toe
- Aluminum and other alloy toes
- Metatarsal guard
- Soft protective toe and abrasion resistant
- Soft toe
Is safety toe the same as composite toe?
Sometimes, yes. Some of the users also take ‘safety’ for ‘comp’. That’s because `steel toe’ is the most popular term and they do not intend to ruin the appetite by using a broader name.
Functions: What are safety toe boots and shoes? what do they do?
As you already know, we encounter numerous risks. Whether you are working in manufacturing complexes, gas stations, oil rigs, warehouses, chemical plants, or construction sites- there are these risks. Heavy machinery may fall on the feet during an intense work shift. Wheels may run over the toes unknowingly. There are puncture risks from beneath, front, side, or the upper parts. Safety toes prevent impact as well as pressure by efficiently minimizing those bad chances. They are usually pre-installed; inserted inside your forefoot part of the boot or shoe covering the toes.
However, you can always buy added safety toes (which are not that recommended). People do not feel as comfortable with external safety toes as they do with internal ones.
Let’s ease our tension with this funny yet informative video which deals mostly with met guards:
Requirements Vary: Do I need a safety toe?
It is better to consult coworkers and the authority before deciding for the first time.
There are safety laws as well as rules for many job sectors. The local/state government may have certain laws, and the insurance company would have taken your signature on some of the prerequisites.
Some employers want steel toes, as these are the oldest ones and thus the most trusted. Many of them do not bother taking comp toes into account. Old school institutions you know!
Others with a metal detector or high electric risk may require nonmetallic safety caps which means various forms of composite/carbon/nano toes.
A number of jobs require metatarsal guards. These are usually the highest-risk work sectors. Some may permit the steel met guards while others specifically require you to wear comp met guard boots/shoes. Some workers use met guards despite their job description does not necessarily require that.
After knowing it well, it is up to you to decide whether to buy steel or composite toes (and as you know, it would be great for us if you could do it with our affiliate links). The same thing you can see in the server industry as well. Many bartenders and waiters wear safety caps though their jobs do not essentially require the safety feature. You can wear them on fall-prone and run-over-prone jobs.
TITAN® safety toe: Timberland’s flagship toe class
Titan from Timberland does not feature any particular type of safety toes. They are currently selling at least 36 products under this tagline. Maybe, Timberland had started the name when they had a plan to do it with titanium alloy. They do have some. Now they’ve moved to comp toes. The name remains as it used to be.
However, this name ensures some crucial aspects. Those are:
- They will be lightweight, meaning no steel toe in the Titan class.
- They will provide a bigger toe room. Again, against steel.
- Asymmetrical. A crucial aspect. We would say, a must-have feature for anatomical fit and elevated comfort.
- Ensured ASTM safety tests.
- Especially last (named after the safety toe) for a perfect natural shape.
Safety toe inserts: just like removable insoles? good or not?
A bit uncommon. You will find a lot on Alibaba and a few on amazon. Buy some steel or other toe caps and put them within the boots or shoes… but wait, there are downsides, right? Yes, because:
- These are not usually as big as they should be. Uncomfortable.
- They will need huge toe boxes to be big enough. Uncommon.
- They will not be as stable as caps should be.
- If glued or sewn, space shrinks and stability goes away.
- No convincing assurance of ASTM/ANSI.
- You will never feel safe with them, at least, the safety measurements should come pre-installed.
- Moreover, they can’t be compared with removable inserts. While the inserts fit well and give you extra comfort and support, these go in the opposite direction.
No, we absolutely do not recommend removable safety toes for serious work.
Can Safety Toes Be Dangerous? Can they completely cut the toes off?
An urban legend where steel and other toes are presented as mythical wrongdoers.
If you can manage ANSI/ASTM steel toe, they are not going to take away the toes. It would take way more than 5 ton to bend your safety cap. But what would happen when there is no safety toe? Everything smashed under 5-7 ton pressure. Steel or other ANSI/ASTM toes could completely save the toes.
You May Not Need Safety Toes: Why & when not wearing a safety toe can be better for you?
When your job does not require safety caps and there is no real threat, you can easily avoid them. You should unless you prefer them. Why?
- Safety footwear comes at a higher price. Even the steel-toe ones do that to your hard-earned cash.
- Specialized toes like comp, carbon fiber, aluminum, and carbon max, etc cost a lot higher. These are upper-class protective products that may not have the least connection to your work.
- They always put on some extra weight. This is the main concern regarding safety toes. If you end up putting on 200 grams of unnecessary weight, you will end up carrying an extra ton per month or two… in your toe tips without any reason. Fatigue is luminous!
- Forefoot upper parts and the soles may crack or wear-tear because of these.
- These somewhat inhibit flexibility. Just think about it, how much would the forefoot be able to bend at ease? Without harming the forefoot shoe part?
- The second biggest concern is comfort. Safety toe boots and shoes tend to be less comfy (unless you are going to spend a lot more for the premium and flagship ones).
- Another common phenomenon is the little toe hurting, resulting in blisters. This is basically a sizing issue.
- Cheap safety boots may fail to protect the toes from heavyweight they should have protected. We’ve seen a dozen `safety cap’ failing under standard pressure. We can never be sure unless buying from big brands’ praised product lines. ASTM and other measurements help a lot.
- Brands not famous tend to make crappy safety footwear fall apart quickly.
- The toe caps need to be bigger and asymmetrical for natural support. Most of brands overlook this necessity.
- Smaller toe box areas may lead to toe deformities.
The solution is clear and crisp. Know whether you are at risk. If you are, buy the better brands. Go for lighter, specialized ones. If not, invest in non-safety toe footwear.